I got this jacket back in January after reading the reviews on BC and DoG. I love this shell (with one caveat).
One reason I bought it is b/c I have super long monkey arms (I wear a 38" sleeve). That being said, these sleeves cover my knuckles. If you don't have really long arms, the sleeves will probably be much too long for you.
The fit, for me, is perfect. I am 6'4", 230. I ordered the XL. The jacket is cut pretty slim. It's perfect in the 30s with just technical thermal under it; I've also found it to be my favorite rain jacket in 40s (with a technical T) and the 50s-low60s with just a T-shirt underneath.
I've also worn it with a Patagonia down sweater when it got a bit colder; the fit was pretty good, but a little tighter than I'm used to. Any colder and I pull out the big jacket, so it doesn't matter that I can't fit any thicker layers.
The reason I didn't give it the full 5 stars is b/c (despite the freakishly long arms) the body is a bit shorter than I like. One of the other reveiwers wrote that the jacket was shorter to make it preferrable for climbing...that may be true, but I'd still like the jacket to be an additioanl 2" long.