This jacket is Goretex Pro Shell, so it laughs in the face of wind and rain. This thing is bomb proof in howling summit winds. That said, the workmanship doesn't even compare to an Arcteryx Pro Shell, even the Chinese ones. The seams are exposed on this jacket instead of overlapped and hidden like Arcteryx does, though both have interior seam tape.
However, the cut of this jacket is why I gave this 3 starts. Given, I'm 6' 2" and 160 lbs, but this jacket makes me look like a turtle. Waaay too big in the body, even with a few layers on. Moreover, the arms on this jacket taper down extremely small, favoring the glove-over-jacket arrangement at the wrists. I prefer pulling my jacket over my gloves, but this jacket's sleeves will have none of it. The tapered arms combined with huge body make the cut even more unappealing.
Also, The zipper has a tendency to jam on the way up, especially in cold conditions. The large zipper flap only exacerbates this problem. Also, the large amount of fleece inside the zipper at chin level feels great above freezing, but collects condensation and then freezes rock hard when the mercury drops. Ouch.
In closing, if you are built like a 50 year old suburbanite with heart disease and wear thin gloves, buy this jacket. It's a great water and wind proof shell.