I love my Scorpions! First shoes I bought, so i was looking for comfort with performance. They feel GREAT, broke in fast, and have been solid for the five months I've had them. I will say though, that already I feel ready for more aggressive shoes. They aren't too aggressive, which frustrates me when I'm working on those tiny cracks on the indoor problems. Also the rubber: I haven't tried any higher end shoes, but the ones I've handled feel a lot stickier.
Bottom line: if you are a new climber: GET THESE BAD BOYS! If you are an experienced climber and like agressive style, look elsewhere.
I'm sticking to La Sportiva for now on.