Id give it a 5 if it wasnt for false advertising. There is no fold out mask or pocket for it and also no media pocket for your ipod.Those are the only catches.Im taking a trip to keystone colorado and didnt want to wear my heavy coat with a thousand pockets so this one really caught my eye. I like it so far the waist gaiter works well and the light wieght I love, Just make sure you atleast have a long sleeve on under it if your up on the mountain. waterproofing works awesome I tested it in the rain tonight but it was a little chilie with just the coat and a short sleeve but I expected that. Over all its a great jacket, just no going in blizzards.