I liked the pants. Compared to other similar pants from other companies I chose these because of their aggressive pricing. Also, these pants come in a Long which is not that common.
I gave them a 5 because of the bang for my buck and the uniqueness of the Long sizing.
They don't have the Kevlar reinforced ankles like some of the other brands, which is a bummer, but again these were a lot cheaper. I used these for 3 full days of skiing and didn't have any trouble with edges cutting the material, but who knows if I would have been as lucky had I been wearing my crampons.
The one thing that was a little weird is that the pants don't unsnap/unbutton at the waist line. Not sure if this is normal or not, but it makes it hard to put these on over bulky underlayers, as the underlayers get caught up in the elastic waistline (I am not talking about long underwear as these would be fine, but rather sweatpants or jeans). Oh and if I gain much weight its going to be hard to fit into these because of the non-opening waistline. People with a large behind should not order too small or you will find it difficult to pull these over your rear end. I typically wear a 33 waist and a 36 length. I ordered a M-Long and they fit me pretty good. Again if I gain some weight I will have trouble at the waist.